The Golden Age of Atlantic Salmon Fishing on the Grand Cascapedia

Date:

Let me nail my colours to the mast straight away. If you care about Atlantic salmon, and I mean really care rather than just ticking rivers off a list, there is no river on earth with a richer story than the Grand Cascapedia. Not the Tay, not the Spey, not the Alta. I know that’s a bold thing for a British angler to say, given we like to think we invented the whole business. But hear me out.

This is a river where a royal princess cast a fly when most Victorian women weren’t allowed near a salmon rod. It’s where an American president caught a fish that weighed more than a decent-sized Labrador, years before he moved into the White House. It’s where the giants of Wall Street built private camps and paid fortunes for a few weeks a year on the water. And it’s where, in 1939, a young man from Long Island landed what the Atlantic Salmon Federation still lists as the biggest Atlantic salmon ever taken on rod and line in North America.

We Brits are funny about history. We’re surrounded by so much of it that we stop noticing. The Grand Cascapedia is different. You can’t ignore it. The pools have names that tell stories, the old camps still stand on the banks, and the guides’ families have been working this river for generations. So pour yourself something warming and let me take you through what I’d call the golden age of the ‘Grand’ – and why I think you should go and stand in it yourself.

Before the gentlemen arrived

First things first. The salmon of the Cascapedia didn’t sit there waiting for a Victorian governor general to discover them. The Mi’gmaq people have lived along this river and fished its salmon for as long as anyone can remember. Even the name is theirs. ‘Cascapedia’ comes from the Mi’gmaq name of the community at the river mouth, Gesgapegiag, usually translated as ‘where the river widens’. Mi’gmaq families had settled permanently along the river by at least 1784.

I think that’s worth saying plainly, because too many glossy fishing histories start the clock when the first man in tweed turned up. The real story is older than that, and as you’ll see, it comes full circle.

The outside world started paying attention after the geologist William Logan surveyed the river in 1843. His reports got anglers talking. But when the sporting writer Richard Lewis Dashwood made the trip in 1862, he was distinctly underwhelmed. There were no rules at the time. Fish were taken by rod and by spear, in season and out, and the stocks were suffering for it.

Then parliament banned spearing, and the river bounced back remarkably quickly. By 1874, the writer George Dawson was describing pools full of fish. Within a few years the Cascapedia had gone from a disappointment to the most talked-about salmon river on the continent. If you want proof that sensible regulation works, there it is, written in the history books 150 years ago.

A princess, a president and a prefab cottage

Americans were already on the river by the 1870s. The most famous was General Chester Alan Arthur, who first came to the Gaspé in 1873 and kept coming back every summer. In late June 1878 he landed a 50lb salmon. According to the Cascapedia River Museum, that was the first giant ever recorded on the river, and the first record-sized Atlantic salmon caught anywhere in North America. Three years later he was President of the United States. I’d love to know which achievement he was prouder of.

But the moment the Cascapedia went from ‘good river’ to ‘legend’ was 1879. The Marquess of Lorne had been made Governor General of Canada the year before. He was a keen angler, and his wife was Princess Louise, Queen Victoria’s daughter. They came to the Cascapedia in 1879, and the Quebec government handed Lorne the fishing rights to the river.

At that point there were no fishing camps at all, just the Woodman house, which had been an inn on the river since 1837. Then, in the winter of 1880, Louise was badly hurt in a sleigh accident at Rideau Hall in Ottawa. Lorne wanted her to have a quiet place to recover, so he had a house built for her by the river. It was called Cascapedia House, and the museum credits it as the first prefabricated building in Canada. It was made elsewhere, shipped by water and assembled on the bank. That building is still there, known today as Lorne Cottage.

This is the bit I love. Louise wasn’t a passenger. She fished, and she fished well. At a time when a woman with a salmon rod raised eyebrows, she took a 40lb fish from the pool now named Princess Pool in her honour. Local legend says she also caught a 50-pounder and sent it home to her mother, who had it stuffed. There’s no hard evidence for that one, but frankly, I want it to be true.

She’s also supposed to have said she preferred the Cascapedia’s mosquitoes to the buffoons in Ottawa. Anyone who has spent a summer evening on a Scottish river with the midges will understand exactly how much she must have disliked Ottawa.

Lorne himself thought the Cascapedia was the best salmon river in the world, and wrote that it was ‘lovely almost beyond belief’. The fishing backed him up. In the summer of 1880, his party, which included Louise’s brother Prince Leopold, caught 80 salmon averaging almost 23lb. Average. Let that sink in the next time you’re celebrating an 8lb grilse.

Governors general, Wall Street and the private camps

Lorne’s cottage started a trend, and the river quickly became the summer playground of Canada’s governors general. Three of them held the rights to it. When Lorne’s term ended in 1883, he sold the cottage, land and water to two wealthy American anglers, Charles B. Barnes and Frederick W. Curtis. They renamed it Lorne Cottage in his honour.

His successor, Lord Lansdowne, arrived on the river on 14 June 1884. He built a camp he called New Dereen, after his family estate at Kenmare in Ireland. He also paid to extend the road up the valley and put in a telegraph line to New Richmond so he could keep in touch with Ottawa. Over four seasons he caught 368 salmon averaging 24lb, with his best at 43lb. That’s not a holiday record, that’s a career.

Then came Lord Stanley, the man the Stanley Cup is named after. He built his camp down in New Richmond rather than on the Cascapedia itself, apparently because his wife couldn’t stand the flies. I have some sympathy. But his son Victor clearly didn’t mind them. On 23 June 1892, Victor Stanley landed a 55lb salmon, which the museum now lists at the top of its record table.

By the early 1890s, the Americans wanted the river for themselves. The lease was sold at auction to a syndicate led by Henry W. DeForest, which became the Cascapedia Club. The original members read like a roll call of the Gilded Age: W.K. Vanderbilt, the financier R.G. Dun, Dr S. Weir Mitchell, Edmund W. Davis and others. The viceregal era was over. Big money had arrived.

And big money built. Over the following decades, ten ‘official’ private camps went up along the river. Dun built Red Camp in 1887. William Mershon built Cascapedia Cottage in 1894, now known as Horse Island. Mershon’s original camp didn’t even have a kitchen, so his meals were cooked by a neighbour, Peter Barter, who charged two cents a meal. I find that oddly comforting. Even the very rich have to sort out lunch.

In 1901, Benjamin Douglass bought a patch of high ground on the east side of Trout Brook. Local builders Evelyn and Robert Brash finished his three-bedroom camp in 1902, with steps down the steep bank to a boat landing in 1903. He called it Douglass-Beck. In 1923 it was sold to Frederick Morgan Kirby, who renamed it Salmon Lodge, then sold it on to James Bonbright within a week or two. That camp is still welcoming anglers today, and I’ll come back to it.

The guest lists over the years were extraordinary. The museum lists George Eastman of Kodak, Bing Crosby, ice hockey legend Bobby Orr and the sporting artist Ogden Pleissner. Governors general, prime ministers and US presidents fished here too.

The real heroes: the guides

Here’s my strongest opinion in this whole piece. The golden age of the Grand Cascapedia wasn’t built by princesses and millionaires. It was built by the local families who guided them.

The museum puts it neatly. The sportsmen owned the camps, but the locals supplied the skill and know-how. Settler families and Mi’gmaq alike became expert rivermen. They poled the anglers up and down the river, read the water, chose the flies, handled the gaff and, no doubt, quietly rescued a great many tangled casts. Look at the record tables and you keep seeing the same surnames among the guides: Woodman, Harrison, Barter, Gedeon.

They also had a front-row seat to the drama. Richard Duthie was one of Princess Louise’s guides, and there have long been rumours of a romance between the two. Edmund W. Davis, who wrote a book about fishing the river in 1904, was found shot near his Red Camp in 1908, and nobody has ever been quite sure whether it was an accident. If those guides had kept diaries, we’d have a bestseller.

The river did something important for the valley too. It gave local people a reason and a means to stay, raise their families and make a living. That tradition carries on. The museum says around 120 people still work on the river today.

As a Brit, this bit resonates with me. Our own great salmon rivers were built on the same relationship between visiting rods and local ghillies, and the best ghillies were always worth more than the most expensive rod in the hut. On the Cascapedia, the guides are still the beating heart of the experience. If you go, listen to them. You’ll learn more in a morning than in a year of YouTube.

The Cascapedia Giants

Now for the numbers that made the river famous. The Cascapedia River Museum keeps a hall of fame for what locals call ‘Grand Cascapedia Giants’, meaning fish over 45lb. It reserves its record table for fish of 50lb and over.

The historian Ronald S. Swanson reckons only 21 or 22 salmon of 50lb or more have ever been recorded in North America. Seventeen of them came from the Grand Cascapedia. Seventeen! No other river comes close, and I’m not sure any river anywhere can match that concentration of true monsters.

The roll of honour reads like a novel:

  • Victor Stanley, the governor general’s son, 55lb on 23 June 1892, on a ‘nameless small yellow fly’.
  • R.G. Dun, the financier behind what became Dun & Bradstreet, with two 54lb fish, in 1878 and on 29 June 1886.
  • Charles B. Barnes of Lorne Cottage, 53lb on 23 June 1911. Sadly, his mounted fish was later destroyed in a 1975 bombing at the Anglers’ Club of New York.
  • Henry Nadeau, a local storekeeper, with a fish of 53 or 54lb from Judge’s Pool on 5 June 1920. According to Swanson, it’s still the largest Atlantic salmon ever caught by a Canadian. I love that a local man holds that one.
  • O’Neill Ryan Jr, 52lb on 24 July 1954, on a 3/0 Lady Amherst. The museum says his two 52-pounders, from different rivers, remain the largest Atlantic salmon caught since the Second World War.

And then there’s the big one. On 27 June 1939, a young New Yorker called Esmond Bradley Martin hooked a colossal salmon in New Derreen’s Upper Jam Pool on an 8/0 Lady Amherst, with guides Lorne Willett and Collins Gedeon. The Atlantic Salmon Federation lists it at 55½lb, the largest Atlantic salmon ever taken on rod and reel in North America. Its exact weight has caused plenty of argument over the years, and the museum’s own table now lists it at 53lb. Either way, it was mounted, and it has since been loaned to a natural history museum in Washington DC.

Personally, I find the argument part of the charm. Show me a great river without a disputed record fish and I’ll show you a river nobody cares about. There’s even an old photograph of the guide Elzear Coull with a fish some say topped 60lb, though there’s no proof of the weight.

The flies tell their own story too. Silver Grey, Black Dose, a Scottish Dee Iron, and the Lady Amherst again and again. Plenty of those patterns came from our side of the Atlantic, which pleases the British angler in me enormously. The museum even named its tea room after the Lady Amherst.

Hard times, and a river that came through

No golden age lasts forever. The Great Depression hit the old American clubs hard. In 1932, the last year of the original Cascapedia Club, only two members made the trip to the coast. You can almost hear the empty rooms.

What saved the tradition was people who refused to let it lapse. Amy Guest bought New Dereen in 1934 and looked after it for almost twenty years, and the museum credits her with helping keep salmon fishing alive on the river through the crisis. The camps changed hands, floods came and went (the 1948 flood swept most of Tracadie Camp downstream), and some of the old buildings were lost. Camp Chaleurs burned down in 1977. Red Camp was demolished in 1982.

The most important modern chapter, in my view, is about who looks after the river. In 1982, the Mi’gmaq of Gesgapegiag joined with their non-Indigenous neighbours in the valley to form a joint company to manage the salmon fishery. Today, the Quebec government describes the Mi’gmaq of Gesgapegiag and their non-Indigenous partners as jointly overseeing the Society of the Cascapedia salmon fisheries. In 1998, a pilot project also gave the Gesgapegiag band the right to sell fishing days on the river.

Remember where we started? The people who named the river are now helping to run it. I think that’s exactly as it should be, and it’s one reason the Grand Cascapedia is so often described as one of the best-managed salmon rivers anywhere.

The late Lee Wulff, a giant of salmon conservation, said that a salmon is too valuable to be caught only once. On the modern Cascapedia, that thinking is front and centre. The giants are still out there because people chose to look after them.

Fishing the golden age today

So here’s the question I always get asked. Can an ordinary angler, someone without a Vanderbilt-sized bank balance, actually fish this river and feel some of that history?

Yes. And honestly, I think it’s one of the great experiences in the salmon world.

Most of the old camps on the Grand remain private. But Salmon Lodge, the camp Benjamin Douglass built above Trout Brook more than a century ago, takes paying guests. If you want to fish the Grand Cascapedia from a building that was part of the story, the Salmon Lodge in Canada on the Grand Cascapedia is, in my opinion, the obvious place to start. It sits high on a bluff above the river, and the veranda view down the valley is the sort of thing those Gilded Age anglers built their camps for.

It’s not a museum piece, either. The lodge was thoroughly renovated in 2011 and takes up to eight rods plus four non-fishing guests, all with private bathrooms. From there you can fish three rivers: the Grand itself, the more intimate Petite Cascapedia and the gin-clear Bonaventure, where guides use periscopes to spot fish and dry fly fishing is the main event. Early in the season you may well be fishing from a traditional long canoe, just as anglers did a hundred years ago. Fish of over 40lb are still landed on these rivers most seasons.

One practical tip from the KD Flyfishing Tours team: Gaspé fishing is a mix of private water, public water and lottery-allocated beats. They recommend booking by 1 November to give yourself the best odds in the main lotteries. Don’t leave it late.

If you go, do yourself a favour and visit the Cascapedia River Museum in Cascapédia–Saint-Jules too. Seeing the photos, the old tackle and a genuine mounted giant will make every cast you make afterwards feel heavier with meaning.

The golden age of the Grand Cascapedia isn’t just a story in a book. The pools, the camps, the guides’ families and the giants are all still there. For a British angler, standing in that river with a Lady Amherst on the end of your line is about as close as you’ll ever get to fishing inside history. Go. You won’t regret it.

Related Articles